Hello Andrew and welcome to WHRF!

That's a very well balanced review. Thank you for taking time to write it.
Domain disputes are a very sensitive issue because on one side we have the owner who's eagerly waiting to get control over the domain, on the other the registrar who needs to make sure the decision is the right one.
Hi Dan,
Happy to be here and look forward to participating in your project ...
Regarding the dispute - obviously, I completely agree. However, I have always thought that registrars need to go that extra step to protect their clients from fraud. As long as they allow their resellers to countinue operating in this manner, these sorts of stories just wont go away - and it truely does affect us all in this industry...